Where does Scotland stand on women's equality?

As we edge closer to the Scottish Parliamentary elections, here at Engender we are rounding off our manifesto focus with a week on women’s rights. Last year the UN celebrated ‘Beijing +20’, the twenty year anniversary of the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action. As a signatory to the UN Convention on women’s rights (CEDAW), the UK is obliged to report against twelve thematic pillars for action. As many of these areas are devolved to the Scottish Parliament, the Scottish Government is also bound to advance women’s rights under its terms.

Last year Engender published an overview of Scotland’s performance and made recommendations relating to existing Scottish Government policies (see some pictures of our event at the Scottish Parliament below). With a new intake of MSPs on the horizon, this is a good time to remind ourselves how Scotland is faring against our international commitments. Here are some updates on five key areas where there has been some movement over the last year.

Women’s poverty

We recommended that the Scottish Government task their independent adviser on poverty and inequality to include focus on gender. This didn’t happen, and her subsequent report does not focus that heavily on gender issues. A number of Naomi Eisenstadt’s recommendations, however, would have a significant impact on women’s poverty, should they be implemented by the next administration. The SNP has committed to doing so in full, as well as establishing a Poverty and Inequality Commission. Should they win the election, we will be watching to see if this affects the Scottish Government’s approach to poverty reduction, which to date has been more or less gender blind.

We also recommended that the regulations and statutory guidelines for the Scottish Welfare Fund be gendered. This has not happened. The guidance remains gender-neutral, which limits the extent to which the SWF can mitigate the egregious impact of ‘welfare reform’ and austerity on women and on gender equality.

Education and training of women

Despite a ministerial focus on occupational segregation by successive Scottish administrations, very little progress has been made. We recommended that the Cross-Directorate Occupational Segregation Working Group should produce an action plan on occupational segregation for Scottish Government and its agencies. That has not happened. Given the likelihood that the SNP will form another majority government in two weeks’ time, it’s worth mentioning that their manifesto commits to a new ‘Advisory Council on women and girls’ with a remit on ‘occupational segregation and other gender equality issues’. Hopefully this will have more teeth than its predecessors, in the event that it is formed.

We recommended that Scottish Government should require Skills Development Scotland “to develop an action plan to address gender disparities within Modern Apprenticeships” as recommended in Developing the Young Workforce – Scotland’s Youth Employment Strategy. Skills Development Scotland, in order to deliver against a requirement in Developing Young Workforce to deliver greater gender balance across its most gender-segregated frameworks, and other KPIs relating to other protected characteristics, published its Modern Apprenticeship equality action plan in December 2015. This plan was produced in consultation with equalities organisations, including Engender, and we welcome it as a significant first step on a journey towards desegregation of the programme.

Violence against women and girls

We recommended that Scottish Government should ensure that Equally Safe is implemented as a matter of priority and strategically linked with wider social and economic policy. Engender was asked to chair the primary prevention workstream of Equally Safe, which explicitly links women’s economic and political inequality with violence against women.

We also recommended that Scottish Government should implement the Council of Europe Istanbul Convention as a means to achieve its commitment to eliminate violence against women and girls. Although the Istanbul Convention is referenced in Equally Safe, an explicit commitment to implementation has yet to be made.

Women in power and decision-making

Since the Scottish Government consulted on gender quotas for public boards in 2014, Engender has called for quotas to be set at 50%. The Scotland Act 2016 devolves this power to the Scottish Parliament and the SNP has committed to legislate for 50% gender quotas on public sector boards by 2020. This is a welcome move and sets a promising precedent in terms of more equal and diverse representation – both in terms of potential future powers over legislated candidate quotas for political parties, and in terms of progress for other underrepresented groups. For instance, we now need to ensure that the detail of forthcoming legislation is inclusive of people of other genders. You can read more about the case for gender quotas in Scotland in our recent policy report Equal Power, Equal Voice and on the Women 50:50 website.

Institutional mechanisms for women

Alongside the Scottish Women’s Budget Group, we have also consistently called for the Scottish Government to improve strategic links between its annual Equality Budget Statement (EBS) and Draft Budget. Clearly, gender budget analysis has limited practical use if it does not subsequently inform policymaking and public spend allocation. Notwithstanding the progress Scotland has made with its Equality and Budget Advisory Group and the EBS, unfortunately the process for 2016-17 appeared to row back on this, with even less coherence between the two documents than in the previous year. For instance, the EBS did not refer to the large cuts to local government budgets, which will have a significant impact on services that are crucial for women’s equality. Nor was recognition that women are disproportionately affected by ‘welfare reform’ matched with targeted funding within spend on welfare reform mitigation. This has to change or else the EBS mechanism will not translate into practical change for women in Scotland.

We will be in contact with new MSPs, committees as Ministers to make sure that women’s rights are visible issues in the early days of this parliament. The next Scottish Government has a chance to up its game on women’s rights and put pressure on the rest of the UK by implementing the Beijing Platform for Action before 2021. It’s twenty one years old - surely it’s about time.

See our asks relating to Women's Rights here

Share this post on …

Comments: 0 (Add)

You must be signed in to post a comment. If you're already a member, please sign in now.


Gender Matters Manifesto: Twenty for 2016Gender Matters Manifesto: Twenty for 2016 This manifesto sets out measures that, with political will, can be taken over the next parliamentary term in pursuit of these goals.

Become a member


Sign up to receive our newsletter here:

Sign up to our mailing list

Receive key feminist updates direct to your inbox: